Not really a shock, but Bill Simmons and Nick Wright dont think Josh is good

if you listen to Simmons' podcast episode from 09/08 called 'Mahomes or Allen (Again???) and a Clippers-Heavy Mailbag With Nick Wright", they trash Josh Allen. They say he is only the number 1 QB in the game (choosen by players and execs) because there is a lack of good QBs (dont quite understand that). That he doesnt have any signature wins (um, I can think of many). Nick says he is only good in wildcard games (huh?). Seems every blown lead is Josh's fault, but we know some guy got fired because of those.

But we can expect this from a Patriots homer and Chiefs homer. Nick proceeds to make excuses for Mahomes being crap last year. The conspiracy now is that Mahomes was hurt early last season and thus produced his bad 2025? hasnt Mahomes been subpar for 2 straight seasons? They proceed to argue which team had the greatest run ever, the Patriots or Chiefs.

https://www.theringer.com/podcasts/the-bill-simmons-podcast/2026/09/08/mahomes-or-allen-again-and-a-clippers-heavy-mailbag-with-nick-wright